I've been listening to it for about 4 hours straight now and here are my initial impressions.
Overall, it's a decent EP. For me, it's nothing spectacular.
The EP opens with
Run It, which I still find absolutely and completely underwhelming for what it's trying to be (a hype song).
This & That is my favorite on the EP, but it's a far cry from reaching even my top 10 SKZ songs. It's definitely the most immediately interesting in a way my brain doesn't have to sort out song on the album.
Farming has a chance to grow on me. It will probably be promoted along with the title track. It does some interesting things with the sounds (both vocal and instrumental) but it's a little discordant (not jarringly so). I can't tell whether the "you got plenty of time" and "you should draw that line" lines are a sample or another vocal effect on one of the members' voices (a la "no one, nobody can stop me" in
Ceremony) but it really feels like nails on a chalkboard to my brain. It could grow on me as other songs with samples and unusual vocal effects have in the past (I'm looking at almost every song from The Sin: Vanish)
The B-sides are very average and fade into background music.
After You,
I Do,
Way Out, and
Back Then all have a similar sort of pop-rock feel.
I Do stands out a bit more in feeling similar in tone to
In My Head from Karma.
I keep laughing at the tonal whiplash between
After You and
Way Out. "I had to catch my breath, saw you walking past / Didn't know someone could turn my world around like that / You took a piece of me, it all happened so fast" versus "I don't wanna see you again in my life / Final words you'll hear from me, "Get lost, goodbye" / Sayonara, adiós, jal ga, au revoir." LMAO in big, bold font.
I've never been fond of any of their "festival version" songs, and
This & That (Festival Version) is no exception.
Overall, C+/B-.